Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: Counterpoint

  1. #1
    Contributing Member Jim Garry's Avatar
    Join Date
    01.04.03
    Location
    Albany, NY
    Posts
    1,877
    Liked: 239

    Default Counterpoint

    Chris recently submitted a letter to the SEB in which FC cars were proposed to be moved to CM. Below is a counterpoint to that proposal which has been submitted to the SEB and given a tracking number of 33582.


    TO: SEB, MAC
    FROM: Jim Garry
    SUBJECT: Counterpoint to Chris Pruett Proposal
    DATE: November 28, 2022

    This letter is offered as a counterpoint to Chris Pruett’s recent letter, ID# 33424, in which it was proposed to move Formula Continental to C Modified with the requirement it use the Hoosier R60A tire.

    While Chris is to be commended for trying to add numbers to C Modified, this proposal would create a new dominant car type in the class which would render the Formula Ford 1600 uncompetitive given equal preparation and driving. This would disenfranchise every autocrosser with a Formula Ford, the dominant car type since 1990 (32 years).

    Simply restricting the tire for FC will not create an equal competition footing between FF & FC. While the tire compound difference would be large on cold days, this would not be the case during warm or hot weather when there wouldn’t be a large enough difference to overcome the FC advantages which are listed below. Furthermore, during wet conditions both FF & FC would compete on rain tire compounds and the FC disadvantage of tire compound would be eliminated.

    Wheels FF: 5.5” x 13
    FC: 6” & 8” x 13
    Tires - Dry FF: 20.5 x 7 front, 22.5 x 7.2 rear
    FC: 20.5 x 7 front (on a wider wheel than FF), 22.0 X 9 rear
    Tires - Wet FF: Hoosier no longer produces a rear bias ply wet tire to fit FF wheels & despite repeated requests have no intention of re-starting. Using the Hoosier FF spec radial wet is a poor choice because they are different heights compared to the dry bias tires and require changing ride heights and re-alignment which is difficult to do on an active grid at a National event.
    FC: Hoosier makes bias ply wets that fit FC wheels using a traditional wet compound
    Regardless of the issues above, in the rain the FC R60 disadvantage is eliminated
    Horsepower FF: ~110 to 115 (depending on which dyno used)
    FC: ~150
    NOTE: I contacted a Formula Continental racer in mid-November who just had his long rod Pinto dyno'd at 152 HP
    Weight FF: 1100 lbs. [Note: FF GCR wt is 1110, Solo is 1100]
    FC: 1200 lbs., all engines
    WT:HP FF 10 at 110 hp. 9.57 at 115 hp
    FC 7.89 at 152 hp
    To obtain a ratio of 10:1 WT/HP for the FC using 152 hp, the FC would have to weigh 1,520 lbs. To obtain a ratio of 9.57 the FC would have to weigh 1,454 lbs.
    Aero The following are quotes from Ryan Neff of Zebulon Motorsports sent to me in an email dated November 26, 2022. Ryan has successfully designed and fabricated countless wings for autocrossers and road racers.
    "Over the extremely old school F2000 wings on all the cars out there currently, even our road-course wing design for Continentals is ~3x more df for similar drag. A real auto-x setup we could make 5, maybe 6 times the DF the stock VD (Van Diemen) type wing package makes. Maybe more. [Jim Garry emphasis.] But, even with the stock wings, the car would be fast. Likely too fast for a tire restriction alone to compensate.”
    "To really quantify it we'd need to do some lap sim work to check it. I suspect it'd suggest we'd need to add something silly like 200lbs to balance out the gains from the aero and power difference.”


    In closing please consider that beyond the balance of performance issues laid out above, it likely isn’t yet time to be concerned about C Mod turn-out. It can be argued that the last few years have been more difficult for Mod cars than classes which don’t require cars to be trailered. The high cost of fuel has likely impacted decisions of whether to tow to Nebraska & other National level events. It can be reasonably argued that more time is necessary to make any decisions on changes to C Mod due to recent participation numbers. FWIW, in New England Region there will be four FF’s competing during the 2023 season.


    Sincerely,
    Jim Garry
    Jim


    I wish I understood everything I know.

  2. The following 2 users liked this post:


  3. #2
    Global Moderator -pru-'s Avatar
    Join Date
    12.02.00
    Location
    Midland, MI
    Posts
    1,539
    Liked: 312

    Default Thanks...

    Jim,

    Thank you for the posting your submission to the SEB/MAC regarding the FC in CM. I can see your point with regard to aero; although, I think “road racing” wing dimensions could be a path forward (i.e. an addition “restriction” along with the R60).

    On the subject of the health of CM, based on National level (Pro/Tour/Nationals) participation over the past several seasons, it is not good. Via MAC member Brad Smith, the SEB has asked the MAC for Modified class consolidation ideas; AM/BM and DM/EM currently being discussed. Given the growth of FM and decline of CM, I can also reasonably argue for a FM/CM merger. To counter this, the FC in CM was merely an idea to jump start the class. I’m open to others.

    Respectfully,
    Chris Pruett
    Swift DB1

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  




About Us
Since 2000, ApexSpeed.com has been the go-to place for amateur road racing enthusiasts, bringing together a friendly community of racers, fans, and industry professionals. We're all about creating a space where people can connect, share knowledge, and exchange parts and vehicles, with a focus on specific race cars, classes, series, and events. Our community includes all major purpose-built road racing classes, like the Sports Car Club of America (SCCA) and various pro series across North America and beyond. At ApexSpeed, we're passionate about amateur motorsports and are dedicated to helping our community have fun and grow while creating lasting memories on and off the track.
Social